Social Work and the Quiet Racism of New Zealand

By Aniram Itufolo

Aotearoa, the land of the long white cloud. A country proud of its multicultural diversity, inclusiveness and its friendly nature. However, the perils and negative effects of the racism that thrives within our country undermine the proud stance we hold in being inclusive.

Being a first generation New Zealand born Samoan in Christchurch forced to assimilate to New Zealand culture, I am well aware of the presence and negative effects of racism as I have experienced this countless times. The way in which racism within New Zealand culture casually presents itself allows it to fester and can manifest into our society unknowingly perpetuating racist ideas. Questions such as “where are you really from?” or statements such as “wow you’re English is really good” have often left me feeling less than and left with an identity crisis.s. A perfect example of this is this YouTube skit in the short film series ‘Misadventures of A Pacific Professional’ written by Tupe Solomon-Tanoai. It depicts the experience of a Samoan woman, Alofa, who holds the position of CFO within her workplace, however her capability is undermined by her colleagues based on her race and her gender. The microaggressions such as the repeated mispronunciation of her Pasifika name, her being asked to make coffees and the looks of disapproval, highlight and perpetuate her colleagues disbelief in her being qualified to do her job, due to her the stereotype that is attached to having brown skin. These types of microaggressions and stereotypes encourage the oppressive structures within New Zealand which limits the ability for those who do not fit as the norm to succeed and reach their full potential.

I know for myself the responsibility I have as a future social work practitioner is to be an agent of change, address racism when it occurs and to be an advocate for equality amongst New Zealand’s diverse population, but what does this mean for Aotearoa social workers as a collective? Do we all have the same understanding and responsibility to speak up? And how does this intersect with the emphasis that is put on practicing in a bicultural way that honours Te Tiriti o Waitangi? Do the radical neoliberal reforms the New Zealand government adopted in the 1980s create a discourse which works to counteract all of the bicultural and inclusive measures that have been implemented so far?

If we look at the history of New Zealand, the failure to uphold and provide Maori with their end of Te Tiriti o Waitangi allowed the opportunity for oppressive structures and systems to form. Harmful stereotypes of Maori were created and are still perpetuated today. The effects of colonisation are still being felt today as is evident with Maori overrepresentation in the negative statistics – stuck within the cycle of remaining in low socioeconomic status which is emphasised here in the health survey . It is a general understanding that many New Zealanders blame this on Maori themselves without acknowledging the oppressive structures that work against their livelihood and wellbeing. These kind of comments are easily located under any Herald article that involves Maori lives. This kind of treatment is not exclusive to Maori and this is evident with the recent terrorist attack in Christchurch. The phrase “They are Us” was circulated frequently in a way to include our Muslim community in Aotearoa, however the use of ‘they’ suggests the are of an ‘other’ category. Leigh-Marama Mclachlan challenges the notion ‘this is not us’ in this article by highlighting the violent racist history of New Zealand that is often dismissed (21 March, 2019).

Policies have been created with the intention to respond to the disparity of inclusivity,  such as the  Pūao-te-Ata-Tū initiative with child protection in the late 1980s. However I believe the day-to-day work of holding people accountable for racist actions is of most importance. Everybody has biases and different lenses that they view the world through: this is a given. However in order to grow and develop into a better society, it is important to be self-aware, not only of our actions but actions of those around us. This means questioning not only myself on where I could be perpetuating racist ideas but also amongst others. We in New Zealand pride ourselves on our diverse and multicultural population. It’s time to back up our words with our actions.

‘Are we there yet? Becoming a harmonious multicultural society’

By ssungeunee

“One of New Zealand’s darkest days” (Ardern, 2019), in the aftermath of the Christchurch terror attack on 15 March 2019, we gathered as one to express our respect, anger, aroha, and solidarity towards our Muslim community. Also, we engaged with a thought that the acts of racism and hatred and devastating terror were done by a white supremacist individual.

Now, we are looking at nearly three months toward this massacre, victims and their families are enduring through hard times and recovering their physical, emotional, and cultural injuries. The government has shown its move to provide support for the victims such as assigning individual case managers, giving residency visas to the victims and their families, and changing in gun laws. Also, setting up an Royal Commission of Inquiry to investigate the specific circumstances that lead to the attack. The public has shown empathy towards shooting victims and the wider Muslim community by using their social media network and donating towards any supports they need. However, not everyone got it right; some of them were displaying ‘fake sympathy’ to commercialise their personal promotion in their social media and there were endless political and racial comments about the victims. Do our prejudices and racial stereotypes ignore to acknowledge the severity of impacts on those people?

Moreover, we can question ourselves that there are further issues that surround the person to commit such a horrific act towards vulnerable people who were just in the ordinary times of their lives. This act cannot come out by overnight; it was the result of the deep-seated Islamophobia, hatred of immigrants, the politics of economic and racial fears that our society is exposed from the populist politics and media influences (Hyslop, 2019). In the mass media’s construction of immigrants they are often represented as an exotic or threatening another group, which produces racist imagery that transforms into negative stereotypes, prejudices, and discourses that frame them into a homogenous group (Spoonley & Butcher, 2009). We desire to separate, establish borders between who we deem different and alarm us to be away from the groups which we label to be a danger for us (Stanley, 2019). As a society, we must reflect on the structural and societal underpinnings of this terror and address how unconscious racism arises into our society to neglect the shared humanity (Hyslop, 2019; Stanley, 2019).

Aotearoa New Zealand is becoming one of the diverse countries in the world. Currently, the net migration rates are estimated at 56,100 (Statistics New Zealand, 2019). More and different people are coming in and settling in this country, and people in New Zealand may feel uncomfortable being bombarded with different ethnicities. They may feel their workplace and economy are threatened by the intruder. But, this cannot be the reason for an extraordinary act of terror. As an immigrant, living in New Zealand for almost twenty years holding New Zealand passport, I cannot say that Aotearoa was always a welcoming country for me. I am no stranger to racist comments, gestures, and looks which, I have encountered over the last twenty years from primary age till now. This is one of the reasons why I choose to study social work; I acknowledge where there is a difference, there is a potential oppression for a particular group to be different such it is not specifically oppressed on immigrants, moreover, there are discrimination in age, disability, sexuality, religion, gender, and race. So, what can we do?

In moving forward, the question we must ask ourselves now is what we can do differently to ensure this unprecedented act does not repeat itself. We need to be aware that the actions of this terror and unconscious racism are strongly connected. Our roles are pivotal to engage different ethnic groups together becoming a harmonious multicultural society. Whether you are Maori, Pakeha, Asian or Middle Eastern we are no different; we may perceive different values, beliefs, and protocols, however, we cannot judge each person as what construction of social world defines to be. The basis of the global definition of the social work profession emphasises on the promotion of human rights, social cohesion, collective responsibility, and respect for diversities (IFSW, 2014). We, as social workers, need to be prepared to incorporate multicultural practice, which we are aware of balancing the cultural differences but also knowing the sociopolitical dimensions that are affecting the person.  

Kia kaha

References

Ardern, J. (2019, March 15). Statement from Jacinda Ardern on Christchurch         shootings. Retrieved from https://www.beehive.govt.nz/release/statement-  jacinda-ardern-christchurch-shootings

Hyslop, I. (2019, March 20). Aftermath [Blog post]. Retrieved from http://             http://www.reimaginingsocialwork.nz/2019/03/aftermath/

International Federation of Social Workers. (2014, August 6). Global Definition of    Social Work– International Federation of Social Workers. Retrieved from    https://www.ifsw.org/global-definition-of-social-work/

Parliamentary Counsel Office. (2019, April 8). Royal Commission of Inquiry into the          Attack on Christchurch Mosques on 15 March 2019 Order 2019 (LI 2019/72)   Contents – New Zealand Legislation. Retrieved from             http://www.legislation.govt.nz/regulation/public/2019/0072/12.0/LMS183988.h        tml

Salter, C. (2019, March 22). Social responsibility: Facebook in the aftermath of the             Christchurch mosque terror attack. Retrieved from       https://stoppress.co.nz/features/social-responsibility-facebook-in-the        aftermath-of-the-christchurch-mosque-terror-attack

Spoonley, P., & Butcher, A. (2009). Reporting superdiversity. The mass media and   immigration in New Zealand. Journal of Intercultural Studies30(4), 355-372.       Retrieved from http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/07256860903213638

Stanley, E. (2019, March 21). How expressions of white supremacy seep through our      society [Opinion]. Retrieved from http:// https://thespinoff.co.nz/society/21-03-2019/how-expressions-of-white-supremacy-seep-through-our-society/

Statistics New Zealand. (2019, May 14). Net migration provisionally at 56,100.      Retrieved from https://www.stats.govt.nz/news/net-migration-provisionally-at- 56100

Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started